Following the tragedy of the horrific incident at Bondi, Australia is confronting multiple critical reckonings. We are seeing a much-needed national spotlight on anti-Jewish sentiment, an ongoing worry about public safety, and questions about the way such an event could occur. However, from the perspective of a public health expert and Jewish Australian, the paramount dialogue we are finally having centers on firearms.
Ten Years of Warnings and a Successful Response
Public health specialists have been sounding alarms about guns for a minimum of a ten-year period. Following the events of the Port Arthur massacre, Australians united and enacted a suite of reforms to curb gun violence nationwide. The strategy succeeded. Before 1996, the nation experienced roughly one large-scale firearm incident per year. In the decades since, there have been extremely rare major events, with none approaching the death toll of the shootings in the 1980s and 1990s.
The Bondi Tragedy and the Function of Current Regulations
Even during the Bondi tragedy, the nation's gun laws were not entirely useless. Reports indicate the alleged attackers might have been armed with manually-operated long guns and at least one straight-pull shotgun. These weapons are limited to firing a one round at a time, requiring a manual operation to ready the next round. While these guns can be fired rapidly with lethal results, they remain far slower and less efficient than the high-capacity, semi-automatic rifles frequently used in international attacks. The casualty count at Bondi could have been much greater if different weapons had been available.
Preventing another Bondi requires national cohesion. Regrettably, we have already seen fissures in the facade.
Legislation Under Strain
Yet, the horrific toll of the attack demonstrates that existing firearm regulations are inadequate. Crafted in the late 1990s with the noblest aims, years have worn away their efficacy. Alarmingly, there are currently a greater number of guns in Australia than prior to the Port Arthur shooting, with some citizens in urban areas reportedly holding collections of hundreds of weapons.
We have been complacent and it has exacted a terrible price.
The Path Forward: Proposed Changes
In the time after the Bondi attack, there have been numerous announcements regarding strengthened firearm legislation. New South Wales specifically will soon introduce a suite of measures to reduce the public danger posed by firearms. The national government has announced a new gun buyback, and there is hope for a national firearms registry, notwithstanding the inherent challenges of aligning state and federal jurisdictions.
These measures are only possible provided that the nation acts in unison. As noted, regarding firearm laws, the country is dependent on its weakest link. This is the reality of the Australian system – regulations in one state are easily circumvented if they can be avoided with a short drive across a state line.
Addressing Common Arguments
We hear the inevitable response that "guns don't kill people, individuals are". This is true in the identical way that aircraft do not fly passengers, aviators do. Certainly, aircraft require operators, but it would be virtually impossible for a pilot to move 500 people overseas without the plane. The horrific violence witnessed at Bondi would be extremely difficult without firearms, and would have been significantly less lethal if the accused individuals had not had access to the weapons they possessed.
Weighing Necessity and Safety
It is acknowledged there are legitimate needs for some Australians to possess guns. Managing livestock or culling pests in many places is extremely difficult without them. A complete removal of guns from the country is not feasible, as in certain contexts they are essential tools.
The achievable goal – the imperative action – is to ensure that firearm legislation are updated to accurately reflect the world we live in today. Australia's laws have long been the envy of the world, but time and distance has done its work and the nation is less secure as it once was. It is critical to take the lessons of Bondi seriously, and ensure that coming Australians are as protected as past generations have been.
As one commentator observed after the Bondi events, "such tragedies just don't happen here". They don't, but only because the country has collectively worked to keep itself safe. As nightmarish as the incident was, there is an aspiration that it can serve as the final tragedy the nation ever sees.